Kayak Sonar Discussion

[jorluivil]

This should be a sticky..............in the funny section.

[oredith]

much more basic question for the sonar pros here:

how much difference does color make, on a scale of
"if it's not in color, you might as well just hold an etch-a-sketch"
to
"with enough knowledge, a monochrome is as good as colored"

I ask because i couldn't really make heads or tails of what my old (came with the yak) hook-4x was telling me. there were no friendly eyebrow shapes. I was primarily using the FF as a depth finder, and just to see what was under me (soft vs. hard surface).

is color FF a "game changer", where I should really just ditch the old monochrome hook-4 and get a new(er) one? or should I try to learn with the old hook-4 before getting a newer FF?

[ful-rac]

Originally Posted by oredith

much more basic question for the sonar pros here:

how much difference does color make, on a scale of
"if it's not in color, you might as well just hold an etch-a-sketch"

If you mean on a scale of 1 to 10...10.

Originally Posted by oredith

"with enough knowledge, a monochrome is as good as colored"

No.

Originally Posted by oredith

is color FF a "game changer", where I should really just ditch the old monochrome hook-4 and get a new(er) one?

Yes, Yes.

Originally Posted by oredith

should I try to learn with the old hook-4 before getting a newer FF?

No.

[chris138]

Originally Posted by ful-rac

If you mean on a scale of 1 to 10...10.




No.



Yes, Yes.



No.

Agree on all counts!

[Sheephead]

Originally Posted by oredith

much more basic question for the sonar pros here:

how much difference does color make, on a scale of
"if it's not in color, you might as well just hold an etch-a-sketch"
to
"with enough knowledge, a monochrome is as good as colored"

I ask because i couldn't really make heads or tails of what my old (came with the yak) hook-4x was telling me. there were no friendly eyebrow shapes. I was primarily using the FF as a depth finder, and just to see what was under me (soft vs. hard surface).

is color FF a "game changer", where I should really just ditch the old monochrome hook-4 and get a new(er) one? or should I try to learn with the old hook-4 before getting a newer FF?

I'd agree with color being very important. Before I went out with "The Darkhorse" I had my color down very low and although I wasn't exactly sure what to look for at the time low color definitely didn't help. Now I run 90-88% colorline (depending on the day) and it's amazing how much easier it is to identify fish.